Archive for July, 2008

Twitter’s move towards semantic info and the “Content Graph”

pete| July 25, 2008 12:17 am

For the past year plus, there’s been a ton of buzz in the popular tech press about “social networking” platforms, applications, and how “the web is becoming an increasingly connected place.” Much of this was led by increasing interest in social networking applications leaders like MySpace, Bebo, and soon after, Facebook which has had a furious year ever since they opened up the platform for integrating outside development integration.  At the same time, the young founder Mark Zuckerberg became known for coining a phrase that has increasingly become part of the popular lexicon for people following the social networking wars - the “social graph.”  It’s a term that for the most part I ignored for a while because I felt it was just a repackaging of the “six degrees of separation” concept. Nonetheless, it’s part of the lexicon now, and when I use the term, you know I’m thinking about my 200+ Facebook “friends.”

The social network phenomenon seems to have dovetailed another popular concept known as the “semantic web” that was (and still is) very hip and elusive idea.   Arguably, Web 2.0 has largely been about interaction and content.   Sites like social networks, twitter, article review sites like digg and reddit, the blog explosion, and reference content like Wikipedia have been some of the cornerstones of this revolution.

Following on the heels of defining Web 2.0, a lot of people began asking - what is Web 3.0 going to be then and what will it look like?  After a bit of thought, people soon came up with the idea of the semantic web - a concept of the web that takes the existing intelligence out there and makes it directly relevant and useful for the individual web consumer.   I’m not going to hash through all of what functions are envisioned in Web 3.0 - there’s a number of great papers/articles out there on that - but imagine if you will, an internet where you don’t start your experience by “googling.”

Think about that for a minute - you don’t search.  So much of  today’s web experience begins with a search for something that you believe is out there and for most of the world Google is the tool to get started.  I do it every day whether I’m looking for web development tricks or shopping for new shoes, I start with Google.  But the semantic web is essentially an intelligence engine that understands content, and understands how (also who, what, where, when, and why) you, as an individual participant in the online community relate to it and can feed you the information, the concepts, and the content that are meaningful, relevant, and timely.  The true nature of how this will work is currently elusive but there are a number of great sites and efforts - Twine, Freebase -  that seek to create that Wikipedia+ experience that will get us closer to Web 3.0.

So what is the Content Graph and why is it important here?

I’ve been observing some of the bleeding edge stuff going on with Web 2.0 lately - how it’s moving into mobile, how every leading tech thinker is now “Twittering” and buzzing around about what they’re doing, what they’re seeing, where they are, who they’re chatting with, and frankly, for months my head has been spinning to keep up and try and filter through what I should be paying attention to and what to ignore - I need Web 3.0 now!  Tonight I saw a great product that kind of flipped on the light switch and reminded me that Content is still king and we live with a highly disorganized web of information.

This does all go back to Twitter.  The past several months there’s been a huge upswing for development of interfaces to work with the Twitter API - apps that work with Twitter are coming out left and right from Twhirl to FriendFeed, to Swurl, to Twitteriffic, and so on.  None of these have ever helped me organize and keep relevant the tweets I get - and I get maybe 20/hour.  Guys like Robert Scoble who “follow” 21,000 people I have no idea how he filters out the stuff he needs to read.  But a new interface to Twitter called Tweenky (http://beta.tweenky.com) is pitched as having the Gmail look and feel to the Twitter experience and it aroused my curiosity.

It’s a beta product right now and can’t handle super high traffic so, understand if you can’t try it out for a while.  I got lucky. But, here’s the gist - Tweenky makes it possible to organize your tweets and makes it possible to experience them in a more contextually intelligent way.  Say I have about 50 people that I follow on Twitter and 10 of them are known Tech bloggers (@Scobleizer, @LaughingSquid, @TechCrunch, etc.) I can assign these guys into a folder where their tweets, in essence, become content with value to me as fed techie news.  I can drop inspiring entrepreneurial thinkers like (@Ross, @KathySierra) into another folder and view them separately.  You’re getting the idea here - I’m making channels of information out of my received tweets.

At the same time there’s an area in Tweenky called “Hot Topics” which just runs a quick search into the Twitter datastream for topics such as iPhone, Obama, or Dark Knight.  I can see what Twitteres out there are talking/thinking about these things and quickly add them to my follow list and drop them into a topic folder.

The key thing here is now, it’s not just the “who” that’s important as much as the “what” - we’ve now crossed over from the social graph back into what I’m calling the “Content Graph.”  Now it’s about what I’m truly interested in that connects me to the content/thoughts of others out there.  It’s not available yet but I could eventually look at who’s talking about “The Dark Knight” and cross reference it with who has high tweet content talking about music and maybe I can tailor a channel here where I’m getting content about great movie soundtracks.  The Content Graph here is more elusive and interesting her because when combined with social data, we’re looking at something that introduces great complexity and a wide degree of inaccuracy.  It will take time and (machine) intelligence to refine it but ultimately, we will see a powerful semantic system emerge as the Content Graph gets deeper, better refined, and understands it’s organic and evolving nature.

I’m excited about Tweenky because someone gets it - people who try to make a social content firehose like Twitter relevant in their online experience continually have to tweek and tune it by following and dropping the right and wrong people - the who is always far from perfect.  It’s been all about “who” ever since the social networks and the social graph concept came out the past couple of years.  Now, with a tool that moves the focus a little away from the who and more towards the what, we’re returning to a sense of how not just content but the right content is important to our online experience.  Figuring how to answer “why” and “how” as part of a user’s experience will also add to the semantic intelligence engine.  [And imagine if you will, how the mobile "location based experience" information can fit the "where" into this puzzle.]

So this is a start - and a great direction to be headed.  The information/content out there is being contextualized, ported, reviewed, and packaged, a thousand different ways and headed in just as many directions.  The metadata itself has metadata and so forth.  But turn the user experience in a way where being able to control and predict content is possible, and we’re getting ourselves closer and closer to the 3.0 Semantic Web.

Twitter BrainDump for 2008-07-23

pete| July 23, 2008 11:59 pm
  • Ok one thing I miss about Tango: it’s easy to email an article while mobile. NetNews/FGator just does clippings- managed only in Feedgator #
  • There’s no point to having 3G on while in standby; and it kills the battery. Apple should’ve made 3G auto switch on with use #
  • installed Twhirl which gives me dual monitoring of the Twitter stream. Interesting to compare and note the API call delay vs. Twitterfox. #
  • @esthersprague - I’m assuming that you’re talking about Chinese Nationals registering to protest in China? They know it’s a cynical idea. #
  • for some people, I’d like to permanently disable their “reply all” button. It’s downright egregious the tact some have over email traffic #
  • one thing I do like about the mobile safari strategy is iP3g bookmark sync-that’s an idea that should drive other apps in the same direction #
  • I can sum up Facebook’s G2 reskin to 97% of FB users in 3 words: Curves, tabs, & width. Other than that, nothing new. *Yawn* #
  • been getting nonstop solicitations from Apple to try MobileMe the past 2 days - hesitating until the news about the product gets better #
  • knol - google’s answer to wikipedia is now in public beta http://knol.google.com #

Powered by Twitter Tools.

Twitter BrainDump for 2008-07-22

pete| July 22, 2008 11:59 pm
  • It’s 9:00 AM. Why did it just start to smell of nuke popcorn in the office? Who eats this stuff in the morning and why? #
  • The new (beta) FB interface is too messy and spartan at the same time in most of the wrong ways. Looks (gulp!) Yahooish too… (900px min) #
  • One week w/ the iPhone and no one can leave me voicemail because I haven’t set it up yet. Contemplating never setting it up now… #
  • I guess it’s identi.ca ’s turn to failwhale it this morning? #
  • given up on Tango & GoogleReader. Newsgator syncs w/ NetNewsWire - the ideal way to manage my mobile/desk RSS addiction (need to annotate) #
  • jailbroken iPhone 3Gs on eBay fetching as much as $2500 each http://tinyurl.com/6xj3jr #

Powered by Twitter Tools.

Twitter BrainDump for 2008-07-21

pete| July 21, 2008 11:59 pm
  • look on my calendar for the next week and I see three jazz jams over the weekend - one private the others open. How stoked am I? #
  • Safari on iPhone is nice but far from perfect. Apple won’t let app devs make an alt browser so Google will exploit this weakness w/ Android #
  • after a week, the GPS on my iPhone works much better now. Googlemaps based, it looks much better than my 6 year old Acura/Alpine mobile nav #

Powered by Twitter Tools.

Twitter BrainDump for 2008-07-20

pete| July 20, 2008 11:59 pm
  • Every time I see that apple “whoosh” icon on startup I do a double take; looks like a crack on the screen. #

Powered by Twitter Tools.

Twitter BrainDump for 2008-07-19

pete| July 19, 2008 11:59 pm
  • @billscher did ya give the SaltLick A spin. Good BBQ inaustin #
  • du Fox Rocks mixung kelis with wham @ bamboo Hut er #
  • Nearlly 1 am genesis will do -that’s all #
  • @ the giants vs brewers. It is hot out here #

Powered by Twitter Tools.

Twitter BrainDump for 2008-07-18

pete| July 18, 2008 11:59 pm
  • is Pandora vs. last.fm the next Sirius vs. XM? Sure looks like it… more importantly do these services now threaten Sirius? #
  • If anyone is listening to Pandora or last.fm on iphone 1, ping me. I’m curious how well they run on EDGE (no wifi) #
  • @petechen well duh, of course I can shut off wifi & g3 on the iPg3… #
  • Initial head2head: pandora blows away last.fm in startup speed 3g AND EDGE only #
  • Here’s why lack of cut n’ paste on iP3g sucks: even if they made tinyURL for iP3g, I can’t c n’ p it to you in twitter #
  • But you know blackberry can #
  • OK, I’m sold… twittertools does the job and more. @kaiyen, good call. #

Powered by Twitter Tools.

Twitter BrainDump for 2008-07-17

pete| July 17, 2008 11:59 pm
  • so google didn’t really make an app for the iPhone. They just linked to mobile versions via safari. Docs is seriously weak. #
  • 大 props to appl on the language interface.中文is seriously easy on iphone. 手写or pinyin. most 人 don’t realize how 大 a revolution this will be #
  • Unlike M/S intl keys, iPv.2 has predictive diacritics. Groß niño façade hôtel über está. Clever but no Arabic, Hebrew, etc. support. #
  • Pandora tangent: why can’t think of a single shredder who can sound anything like George Lynch? The man is a monster on the 6-string axe. #
  • @guykawasaki - that’s gotta be gross sales. 1M sales reported over 3d. @~$199-$499/each. Crunch it: only~120 units sold/store/day - S L O W #
  • just saw the new look to twitter - yay someone learned stylesheets. New search tools to spam your friends to follow you another way. #
  • If think it was @Scobelizer who said Twitter is about who you FOLLOW not who follows you. I agree. Some still can’t figure this out. #
  • @TechCrunch if they’re “testing” a design, why is this happening in production? Do they not have a preprod env.? This is mostly just CSS #

Powered by Twitter Tools.